Serafina's Pizzeria

Serafina's Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of St Johns at 4125 Race Track Rd, is a true celebration of authentic Italian and New York-style pizza craftsmanship. This family-friendly Italian restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere where the aroma of freshly baked pies instantly makes you feel at home. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something more adventurous, Serafina’s menu is a treasure trove of flavors that will spark nostalgia for pizza lovers, especially those with a soft spot for Brooklyn-style pies.

The highlight undoubtedly is their Grandma Pie—crispy on the outside with a fluffy, tender inside, just like Stephen Ventimiglia described, evoking memories of authentic New York pizza with every bite. Each pizza boasts a perfect balance of savory sauce, quality cheese, and dough that’s both light and flavorful. The Regular Cheese Pizza and Margherita Pizza capture traditional Italian flavors with fresh tomatoes and basil, while the Buffalo Chicken Pizza adds a spicy twist for those seeking a more robust taste.

But Serafina’s offerings don’t stop at pizza. The Prosciutto Balls and Zeppolis are delightful starters that pair wonderfully with their homemade red sauce—Michelle Locker’s favorite alongside the gooey mozzarella sticks. For those who appreciate variety, the Sicilian Pie and Stromboli offer hearty, satisfying alternatives. Don't miss out on the Pizza and Meatball Salad, which cleverly blends fresh greens with Italian-style meatballs, creating a vibrant combination of textures and flavors.

Beyond the food, Serafina’s ambiance buzzes with warmth and authenticity. Linda P captures the lively, bustling energy perfectly, where the visible pizza-making process adds an engaging, communal feel to dining in—a little slice of New York right here in Florida. The staff’s friendliness enhances the experience, making every visit feel personal and welcoming, as Brian Sherin attests, filling the void for those who have long searched for genuine NY-style pizza away from home.

Elizabeth Jenkins highlights the spotless, comfortable setting and encourages pizza enthusiasts to plan ahead for busy evenings, especially Fridays, when delivery orders pour in. And no meal is complete without indulging in the Zeppole; these fried dough morsels, dusted generously with powdered sugar, offer a sweet finale that lingers joyfully on the palate.

Serafina’s Pizzeria is more than just a restaurant—it’s a heartfelt homage to Italian-American pizza traditions, delivered with passion, top-quality ingredients, and a sense of community that makes every bite memorable. Whether you’re a local or a traveler craving an authentic pizza experience, Serafina’s is the kind of place where good food and friendly faces come together to create lasting memories.

Contact Information:
4125 Race Track Rd, St Johns, FL 32259, United States
Phone: +1 904-217-7310